Consumer Reports Says Vinegar Does Nothing for Dishwashers

Consumer Reports found a vinegar cycle did nothing in its dishwasher lab. Why the acid can harm parts and what its tester suggests instead.

Close-up of stainless steel forks in a dishwasher rack, reflecting light and showcasing modern kitchenware.
Photo: Castorly Stock / Pexels

Running a cup of white vinegar through the dishwasher is a common cleaning habit. Consumer Reports tested it in its dishwasher lab and found it did nothing, according to House Digest. The organization does not list it among its recommended hacks.

Larry Ciufo, senior test project leader at Consumer Reports, said the trick was “perhaps better than nothing back in the day.” Specially formulated dishwasher cleaners work really well now, he added.

The test matters because the habit is so widespread. House Digest calls the vinegar cycle an unofficial rite of passage for new homeowners, who typically set a glass bowl or cup of vinegar on the top rack and run a hot cycle. Consumer Reports has tested products and home cleaning tricks for 90 years, and the vinegar method did not make its list of recommended hacks.

Why the idea sounds reasonable

Dishwashers collect grease and food debris from dirty dishes, along with hard water minerals and residue from detergent and water. Distilled white vinegar is cheap and seen as eco-friendly, so it seems an easy way to wash that buildup away. The lab result says otherwise. Ciufo described the vinegar as having no effect at all, which leaves little reason to keep it in the routine, even for owners who already have a bottle in the pantry.

What it means for the machine

Vinegar may also harm the dishwasher. White vinegar is typically only 5% acidity, but House Digest reports it can corrode metal that comes into contact with salt. Because most kitchens use salt, it is hard to be sure none is inside the machine. The acid can also dry out rubber gaskets and hoses, which raises the chance they shrink or crack.

Some manufacturers state in their instructions that vinegar is not safe to use in the dishwasher. Owners can check the manual for their own model to see what the maker allows. Because cleaning products and cleaning habits differ between households, the manual is the most direct place to find out what the manufacturer says about vinegar for a given machine.

What Consumer Reports suggests instead

Ciufo recommended a dishwasher cleaner built around citric acid as the main ingredient, such as Affresh Dishwasher Cleaner. For eco-minded households, House Digest points to Finish Dual Action Dishwasher Cleaner, which earned a B from the Environmental Working Group. Product instructions should be followed for the best results.

Readers who descale other appliances with vinegar can compare the options in our guide on descaling a coffee maker with vinegar, citric acid or a commercial descaler.

Source: House Digest