Consumer Reports Ranks Frigidaire’s 7.5 Cu. Ft. Fridge Last, Scoring It 28
Consumer Reports gave the Frigidaire EFR786-RED a 28 out of 100, the lowest among top-freezer fridges it tested. Other Frigidaire models scored far higher.

Consumer Reports rated the Frigidaire EFR786-RED the lowest of the top-freezer refrigerators it tested, with an overall score of 28 out of 100, according to Mashed. The compact, retro-styled model holds 7.5 cubic feet and costs around $300 on Amazon and other retailers.
It has no ice maker or water dispenser. Owners surveyed by Consumer Reports gave it an average of 15 out of 100.
Where the EFR786-RED fell short
Lab tests found poor energy efficiency, with an annual usage cost of $71. Temperature consistency was so-so and the crisper drawers performed below expectations. Consumer Reports also noted that the unit is on the noisy side.
Buyers on Amazon see it differently. They give the fridge an average of 4.3 out of 5 stars, and many use it as a secondary fridge for snacks and drinks. The Mashed report concludes that Consumer Reports’ findings suggest it may not suit as a main kitchen refrigerator. Readers bothered by noise from any fridge can find background in our guide to diagnosing a loud fridge by sound.
How other Frigidaire fridges scored
The same Consumer Reports ranking gave much higher marks to two other Frigidaire top-freezer models. The FFHT1425VV scored 72 and the FRTE1622AS scored 64. Mashed says that puts them nearly level with comparable Whirlpool models.
Reliability data points the same way. In J.D. Power’s 2025 U.S. Appliance Reliability Study, Frigidaire top-freezer refrigerators had above-average reliability, with fewer reported problems than models from Whirlpool, LG and Samsung. Overall customer satisfaction came to 68.2%. Mashed also notes that customer reviews rank Frigidaire among the most overpriced kitchen appliance brands.
What this means for shoppers
Anyone buying a fridge still has the usual questions to settle first: whether a water and ice dispenser fits the budget, whether a side-by-side, top-freezer or bottom-freezer layout suits the kitchen, and how much the unit will cost to run each year. Energy efficiency is easy to overlook in the store and shows up later on the power bill.
The 28 applies to one apartment-sized model and not to the brand’s top-freezer line. Energy cost, temperature consistency, crisper performance and noise are the areas where the EFR786-RED lost points in the Consumer Reports testing.
Source: Mashed



